Back to From the Rabbit Hole

Why Markdown Needs to Grow Up

Thoughts on why the markdown ecosystem is fragmented and what LFM is trying to fix.

Michael Staton Updated Wed Apr 22 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
LFM Extended-Markdown Content-Authoring Observations

Why Markdown Needs to Grow Up

Markdown is simultaneously the best and worst content format. Best because it's plain text, version-controllable, AI-friendly, and learnable in ten minutes.[1] Worst because the moment you need anything beyond headings and paragraphs, you fall off a cliff into fragmented, incompatible extension ecosystems.[2]

The Core Tension

Every library picks ONE syntax for triggering components and refuses the others:

  • MDX requires JSX. Content authors shouldn't need to know React.

  • Markdoc requires {% tag %}. Beautiful system, locked to one syntax.

  • remark-directive requires :::name{}. Expressive, but unfamiliar.

  • Obsidian uses code fences. Works in their app, breaks everywhere else.

Each library treats its chosen syntax as a philosophy rather than a preference.[3] That's the problem.

What We're Building

LFM's response is not to pick a side but to build a normalizer that accepts multiple trigger syntaxes and renders them the same way. An author writing :::callout{type="warning"} and > [!warning] is doing the exact same thing. The syntax is just a trigger. The underlying operation is identical.

Where This Matters Most

For us, it's investment memos, market analyses, and technical specifications. Documents that need:

  • Rich citations with source attribution

  • Floated images with captions (like a textbook)

  • Embedded media (YouTube, Figma, Loom)

  • Collapsible sections for detailed appendices

  • Mermaid diagrams inline with prose

None of these are exotic requirements. They're basic needs for serious content.[4] And yet no single markdown library handles all of them without dropping into raw HTML or JSX.

Sources

  1. [1]
    CommonMark Specspec.commonmark.orgPublished: 2024-01-28
  2. [2]
    The State of Markdown Toolingunifiedjs.comPublished: 2023-06-15
  3. [3]
  4. [4]
    Why We Built Our Own Markdown Pipelinelossless.groupPublished: 2025-03-25